Rebware

Escrow vs. No Escrow on Your Mortgage: A Comprehensive Comparison

Written by

Rebwar

in

Choosing between an escrow account and forgoing one with your mortgage is a significant decision. Here’s a detailed breakdown of the pros and cons of each, with fact-checked information as of late 2023/early 2024.

Understanding the Basics:

  • Escrow Account: Your lender collects a portion of your property taxes and homeowner’s insurance (and sometimes PMI – Private Mortgage Insurance) along with your monthly mortgage payment. They hold these funds in an escrow account and pay the bills on your behalf when they are due.
  • No Escrow (Self-Escrow): You are responsible for paying your property taxes and homeowner’s insurance directly to the respective entities when they are due. You are essentially “self-escrowing” by managing these payments yourself.

I. Escrow Account: Pros & Cons

Pros:

  • Budgeting Convenience: Spreading property taxes and insurance payments over 12 months makes budgeting easier. Large, lump-sum payments can be difficult for some homeowners.
  • Reduced Risk of Foreclosure: The biggest benefit. If you forget to pay property taxes or insurance, it can lead to a lien on your property and ultimately foreclosure. Escrow eliminates this risk. Lenders require hazard insurance, and unpaid property taxes are a serious issue. (Source: Consumer Financial Protection Bureau – CFPB)
  • Simplified Bill Payment: One less set of bills to worry about. The lender handles the payments, reducing administrative burden.
  • Potential for Lower Interest Rate (Sometimes): Some lenders offer slightly lower interest rates on mortgages with escrow accounts, as it reduces their risk. This isn’t always the case, so compare offers carefully.
  • Protection Against Unexpected Increases: If your property taxes or insurance premiums increase significantly, the escrow account will adjust (though your monthly payment will also increase). This prevents a massive, unexpected bill.
  • Required by Lender (Often): If your loan-to-value ratio is high (e.g., less than 20% down payment), your lender will likely require an escrow account. (Source: Fannie Mae Selling Guide)

Cons:

  • Loss of Control: You don’t directly control when and how your taxes and insurance are paid. While rare, errors can occur.
  • Potential for Miscalculation/Shortage: The lender estimates your taxes and insurance. If they underestimate, you may have a shortage and need to pay a lump sum or increase your monthly payment. Conversely, you might get a refund if they overestimate.
  • Potential for Overpayment/Refund Delay: If the lender overestimates, you’ll receive a refund, but it may take time to process.
  • May Not Earn Interest: Most escrow accounts do not earn interest, meaning your money isn’t working for you. Some states require lenders to pay interest on escrow accounts, but this is not universal. (Source: Investopedia – Escrow Account Interest)
  • Monthly Payment is Higher: Your total monthly mortgage payment will be higher because it includes the escrow portion.

II. No Escrow (Self-Escrow): Pros & Cons

Pros:

  • Greater Control: You have complete control over when and how your property taxes and insurance are paid.
  • Potential to Earn Interest: You can keep the funds in a high-yield savings account or other investment vehicle and earn interest.
  • Lower Monthly Mortgage Payment: Your principal and interest payment will be lower, as you’re not paying into an escrow account.
  • Flexibility: You can shop around for the best insurance rates and pay taxes when it’s most convenient for you.
  • Potential for Discounts: Some insurance companies offer discounts for paying your premium annually instead of monthly.

Cons:

  • Responsibility & Risk: You are solely responsible for ensuring your property taxes and insurance are paid on time. Failure to do so can lead to penalties, liens, and ultimately foreclosure.
  • Large, Lump-Sum Payments: You need to be prepared to make potentially large, annual or semi-annual payments for property taxes and insurance.
  • Requires Discipline & Organization: You need to be organized and disciplined to track due dates and make timely payments.
  • May Not Be Allowed: If your loan-to-value ratio is high, your lender may require an escrow account, regardless of your preference.
  • Potential for Late Fees/Penalties: If you forget to pay or are late, you’ll be responsible for any late fees or penalties.
  • Lender May Require Impound Account Waiver: You may need to sign a waiver acknowledging you understand the risks of not having an escrow account.

III. Key Considerations & Recent Trends

  • Loan-to-Value (LTV): As mentioned, LTV is a major factor. Higher LTV ratios (less than 20% down) almost always require escrow.
  • Credit Score: A strong credit score might give you more negotiating power with your lender, but it doesn’t guarantee they’ll waive the escrow requirement.
  • Property Tax Payment Frequency: Some areas allow you to pay property taxes monthly, which can make self-escrowing more manageable.
  • Rising Property Taxes & Insurance Costs: With increasing property values and climate change impacting insurance rates, the risk of underestimating escrow payments is growing.
  • Escrow Waivers: Some lenders are starting to offer escrow waivers for borrowers with strong financial profiles, even with higher LTV ratios, but these are becoming less common.
  • Servicing Fees: Be aware that some lenders charge a small monthly fee for managing escrow accounts.

IV. Fact Check Sources:

Disclaimer: This is not financial advice. This information is for general knowledge and informational purposes only, and does not constitute investment, tax, or legal advice. You should consult with a qualified financial advisor before making any financial decisions. Mortgage terms and requirements vary by lender and location.

More posts